Why I love Sweeney Todd

March 15, 2014

The character, not Tim Burton’s musical… it would be an extremely long article if I wrote on that topic. No, there’s too much to say Sweeney Todd - Johnny Deppon the film. Go watch it if you haven’t, you won’t regret it. Anyway, what made me write about this? A few days ago we spoke in class about the musical and I prepared a presentation on Tim Burton’s Sweeney Todd. At the end of it, I was asked why I chose that film and why I like the protagonist. I don’t usually think about why I like a character (at least, not on the spot), but here are some of the reasons.

The cast. I absolutely adore Tim Burton, Alan Rickman, Helena Bonham Carter and Johnny Depp. So this makes it easy for me to follow their characters, to try and see things from their perspective. I haven’t seen the musical from 1979 and I doubt I ever will. I don’t think I could feel any kind of sympathy or empathy for Sweeney Todd if he were played by anyone but Johnny Depp. I spoke about this aspect before, there are actors or actresses who simply must play a character; Tim Burton knew what he was doing when the cast was chosen. I have yet to see a character played by Depp and not love (or at least like) him. He is a brilliant actor. I just love it when someone can fully step into the skin of the character, understand it and make the viewer like the one who’s supposed to be the villain of the story.

tim burton johnny deppWe see the world through Sweeney’s eyes, so we have access to his motivations. I’m willing to bet that, if the story was told from a different perspective, we wouldn’t feel the same empathy towards him. Seen from the outside, his deeds aren’t exactly excusable. Knowing his reasons… well, things change. You can’t write off his crimes as unimportant, but you can’t really point fingers either. Again, you have to ask yourself: how far would you be willing to go if you were unable to find help anywhere else? My guess… very far. We’re talking about a man who had been robbed of everything he once held dear; coming back – perhaps with a shred of hope – he finds nothing that might pull him out of darkness. Nothing but his thirst for revenge. Not just for him – and this is important – but also for his wife and daughter. Blood and pain can only be washed away by the blood of the true villain, judge Turpin (and I cannot go all fangirl over Alan Rickman… at least, not here and not yet).

Sweeney’s dead from the moment we first see him , but there’s more than meets the eye in him. We tend to say that he barely shows emotion… and we’re not that far from the truth, especially when the oozing blood tends to be the only way his feelings can beSweeney Todd released from the shackles of his soul. When you watch the film, study his gestures and the expressions that cross his face, you see that there’s something else there. You will notice that he does not kill the man who has a family. Even more, there are times when his eyes betray a deep sense of sadness and longing. He doesn’t want a new wife and/or children, he wants his old life back, but knows that his wish will never come true. No wonder he considers the straight razors his only friends… they are the only link to his past life, the ones who never betrayed him and the ones who not only helped him kill judge Turpin, but also set him free from the strongest jail: his own body and mind.

His goal is quite honorable (granted, not exactly orthodox), even if the way he achieves it isn’t. He is only human, one who has lost faith in every person and institution who was supposed to protect and help him. What is he to do? Again, what would anyone do to protect the ones they love? And I am not talking about what one should do, but about what one does when (s)he is desperate. Hurt, destroy, make the offender pay. Sweeney Todd is on the verge of insanity, you couldn’t really reason with him even if you tried. He keeps on going for revenge and for the memory of his wife. When he no longer has these forces to push him forth, he embraces death.

tumblr_mys4baLUyR1t94sp3o1_500To wrap this up… as much as I hate to admit this, Sweeney Todd is a villain, but a complex one, just the way I (we) like them. He defies our expectations, he shows us that we cannot label a person good or evil, that appearances are not always everything. To me, Turpin is more of a villain than Todd is, but the society in which they live sees things differently. I love the fact that we are offered characters that actually represent different types of people, flaws and insanity and all. Brilliant film, brilliant protagonist! Even if some did not like it… I don’t care, I enjoy it every time I watch it and always discover something new about the characters.

Sweeney Todd Full Soundtrack


by Elena Atudosiei

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , ,

8 Responses to Why I love Sweeney Todd

  1. Vlad-Ovidiu on March 15, 2014 at 10:04 am

    Edward Scissorhands magically gets hands(the shaving rasors are a phantom limb syndrom :)), Snape is a prick as usual and Bellatrix Lestrange makes pies. Brilliant! Anywhoo… back to Depp’s character. He is gentle and ruthless, insane yet meticulous. A complex character indeed(and that’s why we love him) He imprisons himself and we barely get a glimpse of his happiness and humanity. His streak of white hair is a mark of the pain he has endured as well as is his constant expression which leads us to feel that only his body is present while his mind is constantly looming on his drama and planning the ways in which he can obtain his revenge. The last trait of his expression is revealed in the end when the boy appears: resignation.
    There is one last thing I would like to mention. Sweeny Todd is funny. Yes… funny. Especially in the scene with Miss Lovett where they plan their future venture and the “shavings” that follow

    • Elena Atudosiei on March 15, 2014 at 4:52 pm

      I agree wholeheartedly. I can’t believe I forgot to mention he’s funny. And the music is lovely; there are parts when I have to dance around the room.

  2. Mihaela on March 15, 2014 at 12:47 pm

    Sweeney Todd is a fascinating character and is so, firstly by the fact that Johnny Depp portrays him so brilliantly(with Tim Burton’s help) and secondly, I think, because we tend to sympathize with him. Personally, I sympathize with Mrs. Lovett as well, but it’s hard not to understand Sweeney’s lust for revenge. As much as I try I still don’t manage to see him as a villain, not him or Mrs. Lovett. “Desperate times call for desperate measures” they say, and I tend to agree with them. This is the miserable Victorian age where only the rich are somewhat happy and the poor are struggling to survive. Toby’s character is a truthful representation of those times, a small child forced to work at an early age and having to face all the horrors that no child should endure. Judge Turpin is the true villain, living the privileged life and condemning the innocent and poor, while Sweeney and Mrs. Lovett represent the oppressed masses that no one cares about, so they have to make due with what life gives them. I think these two were changed by society’s hard treatment on them, they learned to adapt and in doing so, became as rotten as the world they lived in. What I really love about this movie is the fact that in the end, all of the corrupted characters get what they deserve, including the episodic character at Bedlam, the jailor that gets attacked by his blonde female prisoners. And even though I empathize with Sweeney Todd and Mrs. Lovett, I wouldn’t have wished for them a different ending than the one presented in the film.

    • Elena Atudosiei on March 15, 2014 at 5:05 pm

      I think that, when it comes to films, I have found my soulmate in you 🙂 Thank you for the wonderful comment!

      • Mihaela on March 15, 2014 at 7:16 pm

        You’re very welcome! 🙂 It’s so amazing to finally meet someone that loves these movies like I do! Keep writing these awesome articles and thank you for making this weirdo feel less alone in the world.

        • Elena Atudosiei on March 15, 2014 at 8:17 pm

          I’m a weirdo too 😀 And damn proud of it, too! There are so many good movies and great actors/ actresses/ singers (yes, I’ll get there too), I can’t wait to write about each and every one of them.

  3. Graziela Duran on May 28, 2014 at 6:39 pm

    I liked it Elena Atudosiei. I agree with you when you said: “He defies our expectations, he shows us that we cannot label a person good or evil, that appearances are not always everything”. For sure Judge Turpin is the villain and for being a judge he did what he wanted. What a pity of that kid who was sentenced. And poor Benjamin that after all that happened with him was arrested. I understand the revenge of Sweeney against Turpin, but what a pitty that he stayed insane and started to kill anyone that crossed your way.

    • Elena Atudosiei on May 28, 2014 at 7:07 pm

      I love Tim Burton’s films. He did a great job with Sweeney Todd and I want to write a review for the entire film sometime over the summer. There’s a lot to say about the plot and the major characters. I’m happy to have found another Burton fan!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *